Library Square - Downtown Falmouth
352 Main Street Falmouth MA 02540
508-540-8777

Our Pies


All our pies are made with local, organic fruits whenever possible. We flash freeze what we can't use in-season to enjoy throughout the year. All our pies are made from scratch. You will love our delicious, flaky butter crust. We use only natural ingredients in our pies, no preservatives and no shortening (hydrogenated oil.)

Shipping


Our pies are flash frozen, packed in special dry-ice containers, and shipped within 24 hours of your order via UPS 2nd Day Air, to ensure prompt delivery and the freshest taste possible.

Please Note: We can only ship to one address per order. For multiple pie deliveries, please place a separate order for each shipping address.

Payment


We use PayPal for secure online transactions. Once you have finished shopping, you will be brought to a PayPal payment page, where you can pay with credit card or PayPal account. You will also provide your billing and shipping information on this page.

Checkout


Use the button below at any point to view your cart or checkout.

Pies a la Mode homemade apple pie $24.95Apple Pie

Our Apple pies start with tart Granny Smiths and then we always add a little something extra, a few Cortlands or local Jonigolds when possible. Always delicious, never the same.

Pies a la Mode homemade apple pie $24.95Apple/Cranberry/Walnut Pie

If you want color and crunch in your dessert, try this pie. Our apple pie with local cranberries we get from the Pearl family in Carver, and walnuts which add a great nutty crunch. Although this pie is a fall favorite, we also freeze the berries so our customers can enjoy this pie year round.

Pies a la Mode homemade blueberry pie $24.95Blueberry Pie

The combination of wild and cultivated blueberries really make this pie stand out. The size differences, and the flavor of each berry has its own nuances, fresh from Cape Cod and Maine, a great combination. Never too sweet, never too tart.

Pies a la Mode homemade strawberry pie $24.95Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

The lattice crust says it all. A beautiful pie that that is delicious as well. Local rhubarb and strawberries are harvested in the spring, both of these fruits freeze extremely well for you to enjoy year round.

Pies a la Mode homemade chicken pot pie $24.95Chicken Pot Pie

All white breast meat, sauteed, poached for hours, along with our delicious white sauce, peas and carrots enrobed in an all butter hand rolled crust make this dish the perfect comfort food. We've been saying for years 'the best chicken pot pie on Cape Cod', now we want everyone to be able to enjoy it. The perfect meal, the perfect gift.

Pies a la Mode homemade lobster pie $65.00/Set of 4Lobster Pot Pie

Big chunks of Cape Cod lobster tail and claw meat in a delicious sherry sauce. Individual size 8oz serving in a reusable ramekin is a rich indulgence for the lobster lover. Shipped in sets of four.